Pilots forced to cut corners on safe fuel levels, networks say

To what extremes will airlines these days go to cut costs? Passengers might be alarmed to find out one of the more worrying answers uncovered in a major NBC and MSNBC.com investigation: Fly their planes knowingly on low fuel levels.

The networks have delved into a Federal Aviation Administration database of non-public safety complaints to unearth a significant amount of safety concerns raised by pilots themselves, who say airlines are forcing them to fly major commercial airlines with too little fuel.

The networks quote internal memos from Continental Airlines that appear to take pilots to task for making “indiscriminate” fuel stops en route to its hub at Newark Liberty International Airport, saying that they cut down on profit sharing and pension funding.

The Transportation Department last week released a report saying flights declaring minimum or emergency fuel levels are increasing for routes into Newark, based on a sample of 20 landings.

The FAA says all flights must have enough fuel to reach their destination plus their farthest alternate airport, and then must carry another 45 minutes’ worth in addition to that, the networks say.

The FAA also gives pilots final say in the amount of fuel they carry on their flights. But the networks’ report says that increasingly, the judgment of pilots is called into question if he/she raises concern about the amount of fuel designated for the flight in the flight plan

Says one captain quoted in the report: “I, as captain, have final authority on what I deem is a minimum safe fuel load for the flight or do I not.”

Read the investigation: It’s thorough and explains the extent of the concerns, and also includes excerpts of pilots’ complaints.

As Gadling’s resident cockpit expert, I’d be keen to read Kent’s take on all this, if not on the thrust of the networks’ investigation than in general on the role pilots have in setting fuel levels for flights and just what it means for a plane to be descending claiming minimum or emergency fuel levels.

As someone who has never been in the cockpit, I’m out of my league in these matters. Is this report something that should concern us?

What strange things have been found on planes?


Click the image to read the bizarre story…

Irate customer to American Airlines: I may give up traveling altogether

Antonia Bell from San Antonio wrote me recently, upset that she could not send a letter of complaint directly to American Airlines through its Web site — something wasn’t working.

Bell is one of the thousands who were left high and dry during the airline’s massive round of flight cancellations a few weeks ago. Bell was responding to a post I wrote reporting that a group of AA pilots have just launched a Web site of their own and are looking for irate customers to post their AA horror stories for the world to read. AA recently launched its own blog that I can only imagine might work in part to offset criticism it receives in other forums.

Anyway, Bell was kind enough to send me the letter that she has faxed to American. Nothing earth-shattering here, but I wanted to share it with you:

April 9 2008

American Airlines Customer Relations
Mail Drop 2400
P.O. Box 619612
Dallas/Ft. Worth Airport, TX 75261-9612

I couldn’t even get this complaint to go through from your website—-why am I not surprised? I know I’m probably just one of the thousands of complaints you’re receiving as a result of your flight cancellations, but if there’s anybody who cares up there, this is why I’m done with American, after 30 years of being a customer:

  1. Your e-mail notification system didn’t work…I only found out about the cancellation because of news stories.
  2. Miraculously, I got thru on your 800-number yesterday about 5:30-6PM CDT. The young lady I dealt with said she was reticketing me on CO 1505/1629 and putting notes to that effect on my record (Record Locator: PCHGPR). When I got to the airport this morning, she had done neither, and the CO flights had sold out several hours earlier (middle of the night, I’m guessing).
  3. Your Automated Response telephone system consistently misrepresents how long the wait is, and in some cases is contradicted by a later recording. At 4AM this morning, it said the wait was 58 minutes…..1.5 hours later, I was still on hold.

Your systems are broken, and nobody seems to care. I cancelled my trip, since there was no point in going at a later time. When I rebook, it will be with another carrier—-or I may give up traveling altogether.
For business, travel isn’t really necessary with the technology that’s available. That will probably be the death of the airline industry.

Antonia Bell
San Antonio, TX

How long is too long on a tarmac?

Many people, who have flown frequently, have probably had their plane taxi out to the runway and sit and sit and sit for what seemed like an extraordinarily long amount of time. Peering out the tiny windows, people have wondered, “Why me? Why now?”

They’ve possibly fiddled with the window shade, putting it up for a bit and down for a bit for something to do. After awhile, they can list several items from the airline’s duty free catalog and which movies are on which route. If left sitting there long enough, people may wonder what the tipping point is for a nervous breakdown and if they, perhaps, have wandered into the set of a horror movie. They may even curse their fate that if they must be stuck on an object that’s supposed to move, it’s not the London Eye, the world’s largest Ferris wheel. If stuck on that thing, people get better service than on an airplane.

With summer travel rapidly approaching, the being stuck out on a tarmac scenarios have not improved much since last year. The gap between what passengers think is a time they can be stuck on an airplane without going bonkers, and the airline industry’s version, is not any closer because there hasn’t been a length of time established for when extra services need to kick in. Airlines view”Trigger thresholds,” within a range from “30 minutes to two hours on arrival, and from 90 minutes to three hours on departure.” When it comes to deplaning, thresholds “range from 30 minutes to five hours on arrival and and between one and five hours on departure.” What is to occur during delays isn’t established either. Do customers get a snack? water? sympathy?

According to this AP article about this stuck on a tarmac issue, to avoid spending part of the summer in a metal cylinder with wings, unsure of when life will move forward, don’t fly in or out of O’Hare in Chicago, Minneapolis/St. Paul or any of the three major New York City airports. Here’s a detail that gives some insight into why being stuck is not uncommon. Northwest Airlines has 56 departures scheduled for a 15-minute window in Minneapolis/St. Paul. That number is physically impossible to meet.

%Poll-12849%

Beware the nose-picker: 10 not-so-common air travel complaints

The flight attendant whose skirt is too short. The seat mate who picks his nose…and eats the result. The passenger vexed by an odd vibe on the plane, and who insists the flight is haunted.

Chances are these types of things do not top the list of complaints that frequent fliers among us might lob at their airline of choice. We typically are miffed about late departures and delays, Draconian security measures at the airport, lost baggage, that sort of thing. Maybe there are a few of us who feel slighted for having to shell out for booze on international routes on American carriers.

Well, veteran fight attendant and MSNBC.com travel columnist James Wysong has a few not-so-common consumer complaints he’s heard during a 20-year career in the skies. “10 Wacky Complaints About Air Travel” has a few objections that we’ve all probably had over the years (like how to deal with a gassy passenger) and perhaps a few we haven’t (would anybody really care if their favorite airline switched from Pepsi to Coke?).

My favorite: The man with questionable English skills surprised at the water-landing portion of the inflight safety procedural. Alarmed that no one had informed him that this particular flight was landing on water, he confided to Wysong that he could not swim.

American Airlines: Tell its pilots your travel horror stories

American Airlines customers: Are you angry at the company? Well, AA pilots want to hear from you.

Following a week that saw the carrier cancel more than 3,000 flights, leaving tens of thousands of passengers stranded, a group of AA pilots has just launched a Web site — Tell Your AA Story — where they want you to air your frustrations about the airline’s recent and future performance. The site has already generated more than 56,000 hits.

Check out this welcome message, taken directly from the site (the caps are not mine):

Had your travel plans destroyed by the actions of AA lately? Even if they’re not listening–we are. Whether you were traveling on business, for pleasure, or for an emergency, we realize that the mismanagement of American Airlines has cost you dearly. It doesn’t matter if you lost a day at Disney with your family, a day of work for your business, or a major family event, the unfortunate truth is that your life has been disrupted, your plans destroyed, your business derailed–all for one bad reason: THE PROFIT OF A FEW AMR EXECUTIVES.

AA’s 12,000 pilots are in the middle of contract negotiations, so the site’s launch seems as much a collective bargaining move as a response to last week’s cancellations, even as the Allied Pilots Association, the pilots’ union, says it is neither.

If you’re flying out of Boston, New York, Miami, San Francisco and a handful of other cities today, you are likely to encounter a few dozen AA pilots outside protesting the company’s recent performance. At key hubs, 30-50 AA pilots will be passing out literature promoting their new Web site between 11 a.m. and 2:30 p.m.

This just as American says it is back up and running at a full schedule (the pilots say their actions will not translate into flight delays). AA clearly has more than just frustrated customers to be concerned about. I’m reminded of Grant’s post earlier this month about an AA flight attendant who used an awards ceremony as a forum to take AA management to the woodshed over a whole host of consumer and safety issues.