Gadling gear review – Sony Ericsson C905a on AT&T Wireless

Every now and then I try to expand my horizon and review a phone not getting the attention it deserves. Sure, phones like the Apple iPhone and the T-Mobile MyTouch 3G may be the ones getting all the cool TV commercials, but what if you just need a good solid performing phone that won’t break the bank?

The Sony Ericsson C905a is such a phone – it looks like a phone, feels like a phone and yet it still manages to offer a good lineup of features making it worth some attention.
The basics

The basics are all there – this is a Quadband GSM phone with International 3G support. It features GPS, email, mobile music and TV services and games. One feature inside the C905a that sets it apart from most other phones is an 8.1MP “Cyber-shot” camera, with a real flash.

The entire front of the phone slides open to reveal a keypad, and on the top of the phone are some buttons to control the camera.

The Sony Ericsson C905a phone – as a phone

This is where the C905a excels – as a phone. If your idea of a phone is being able to slide the keypad open, and start dialing, then you’ll love the C905a. There is no “phone application” and no complicated array of options to reach the dialer. Just a real keypad and instant dialing. Voice quality is what you’d expect from a Sony Ericsson – crisp and clear. Volume is loud and there is virtually no static or hiss.

What I did not like was the side-mounted charging port. If you need to make a call and charge the phone at the same time, you need to get used to the charger sticking out the side.

The phone itself doesn’t look particularly special – in fact, it looks very much like most other non-smartphone devices on the market. That said, it does feel well made. The sliding mechanism is extremely smooth, and there is no “squeak”.

The user interface

The menu system in the C905a immediately felt familiar – most likely because it hasn’t changed much since the Ericsson T68 I was using back in 2001. The basics are identical. This could mean a lack of innovation, but it could just as easily mean Sony Ericsson did not want to mess with something that works. Personally, I’m leaning towards “lack of innovation”.

The “interface from 2001” is very easy to use though – menus are logical and most functions can be found without the need for the user manual.

The phone also lacks a regular headphone jack, and the box does not include the special headset you need. It does support Bluetooth streaming music.

The camera

The camera lens is hidden behind a sleek sliding cover giving the whole thing a real camera “look and feel”. In fact, it if weren’t for the AT&T logo on the back, you’d have a hard time knowing this was actually a mobile phone.

The camera in the C905a looks fantastic on paper – a Sony Cyber-shot 8.1 megapixel auto-focus camera, with a xenon flash. Sadly, “on paper” is where those specifications stay, because in real life, the performance is sloppy. Don’t get me wrong – it’ll outperform an iPhone 3G in almost any situation, but I really had expected more from a camera carrying the Sony name.

The photo I inserted above looks good – but it took me 12 photos to get something worth using. Performance of the camera is sluggish, and even when set to “auto contrast mode”, photos turn out dark. To make matters worse, the C905a only cares for the Sony M2 memory card format, which means all your SD and MicroSD cards are worthless. M2 cards cost about 2-3 times more than MicroSD.

Final thoughts

Here’s the thing with these non-smartphones (some people call them dumbphones). If you came from an iPhone, Android powered G1 or other smart device, I can pretty much assure you that the C905a won’t impress you.

If you have been able to resist the urge to spend your cash on a smartphone, and just want a phone that is, well, a phone, then you’ll love the C905a. It performs where a phone needs to perform. It delivers just what you need, as long as your idea of a phone is not a device that will let you play Guitar Hero on the bus.

Sadly, I’ve been walking around with some kind of smartphone since 2000 when I purchased the horrible Mitsubish Mondo. As a smartphone user, I don’t see myself making the step down to a dumbphone. The sacrifice is simply too high. I kept trying to press things on the (non touch) screen of the C905a, I got annoyed trying to enter stuff without an on-screen keyboard, and trying to surf the web was about as much fun as a wet fart in a spacesuit.

But if I move myself back 9 years, till the pre-smartphone era, I can vaguely remember a time when I would have loved the C905a – it was a simpler time, a time when we used our computer as a computer, and our phones as a phone. Sadly for me, there is no turning back – but I’m convinced there are still plenty of people out there who still enjoy the simpler times.

This brings me to the worst piece of news about the C905a – even though this is “just a phone”, AT&T Wireless wants $230 from you if you decide this is going to be your new phone. They’ll give you a $50 mail in rebate credit, but that still makes it about the same price as an iPhone or Blackberry Bold. Perhaps now really is the time to move on to something smarter?

PROS: Great lineup of features, GPS, several AT&T applications included on the phone (navigator, TV, music).

CONS: Price, poor camera performance, M2 memory card format, no headset included, some AT&T applications cost extra.

PRICE: $229.95 (179.95 after a $50 mail in rebate).
Available from: AT&T Wireless, online and in retail stores

Tweet your Slacker music discovery experiences

Regular readers will no doubt know that Slacker is one of my personal favorites in the busy world of online music services.

Since I first wrote about Slacker, they have added an iPhone and Blackberry player to their lineup.

Starting tonight, Slacker users will be able to share their music experience by sending a variety of stuff to Twitter. The list of Tweetable (is that even a word?) options is:

  • Station changes/plays
  • Favorite Song
  • Banned Song
  • Banned Artist

So, next time you come across a song you really love (or hate), Slacker will share it with all your devoted Twitter followers. There are some other Twitter-sharing music services out there, but the Slacker integration sounds really easy to use.

If you’d like to set up your Slacker/Twitter integration, head on over to the Slacker Community page (live tonight at 9pm EST). In the meantime, why not head on over to Twitter and follow us!

FLO TV brings TV on the go – keeps kids quiet during long drives

I’ve been following the mobile TV market for some time now – I have a particular interest in this stuff, as it means the difference between 4 hours of “I Spy” or 4 hours of listening to my own music while the back seat passenger listens to Dora.

FLO TV has been available through mobile operators for some time now, but today, Qualcomm has announced the FLO TV personal television – a true portable TV solution.

The FLO TV itself is a $249.99 3.5 inch touch screen TV, with a built in kickstand and speaker. Browsing channels appears to be pretty easy, and the channel lineup includes content from MTV, Comedy Central, Nickelodeon, CNN and more.

Sadly, TV on the road does not come cheap – all this entertainment will cost you $8.99/month. In the fine print, you’ll find that the $8.99/month price is only valid on a three year prepaid plan.

The FLO TV personal television will be available later this year, just in time for the holiday season. If you can’t wait, you can get FLO TV on selected AT&T and Verizon devices, check this page for more information.

(Via: Engadget)

Gadling gear review – IPEVO Skype and VOIP handsets

In this 3-in-1 review, I’m going to show off three different Skype/VOIP handsets for your computer. IPEVO, the company behind these three handsets has been producing some of the best selling VOIP equipment on the market for several years, so it makes sense to take a close look at what they have to offer.

In the review, I’ll show you the ST-4RT.1 universal VOIP handset, the FR-33.1 Skype USB handset and the TR-10 Speakerphone/handset.
IPEVO ST-4RT.1 Universal VOIP handset

The ST-4RT.1 is the simplest of the three phones on review today. It isn’t much more than a lightweight handset with headset/microphone connectors. That said, at just $14.99 (with free shipping), VOIP handsets don’t get much cheaper than this.

It features a volume control dial, and 2 color coded plugs. You don’t need to install any special software, and don’t need to make any changes to your audio setup, with the possible exception of fine-tuning the microphone. It weighs just 2.1 ounces, making it ideal for any carry-on bag.

Sound quality is perfect for VOIP calls, and since it doesn’t rely on software, you can use it with any VOIP application, including Skype and Magicjack.

IPEVO is currently running a promotion on this handset – if you order a two pack of them, you’ll only pay $20, or just $23.99 for three!

IPEVO FR-33.1 USB Skype handset

The FR-33.1 is the best selling USB Skype handset in the world – and rightfully so. This thing is a real treat to use. With the FR-33.1 you don’t need to touch anything on your PC to make a Skype call. The IPEVO software communicates with your Skype installation, and the keys on the handset provide full control. You can dial, browse speed dials, control volume and more.

It weighs just 3.5 ounces and retails for $29.99. This really is the handset you’ll want if you make a lot of Skype calls on the road. I found that while the handset is designed for Skype, that you can still use it for any VOIP application, as it just shows up as an audio device. The keys will only work with Skype though.

Like on the previous handset, IPEVO is also running a promotion on this one – a two pack is currently on sale for just $43.99.

IPEVO TR-10 Portable conference phone

The third and final handset in this lineup is the TR-10. This curious looking handset does several things in a single device – it is a normal phone handset, a portable speakerphone and a USB computer speaker.

It is in its element as a speakerphone, and really will allow you to make conference calls with surprisingly good quality. Stuck in your hotel room with 6 others, and need to make a call back to your office? This $59.99 is on par with those $500 conference phones found at most upscale offices.

On the front of the TR-10 are controls for volume, mute, call control and on the side you’ll find a button for switching between handset mode and conference phone. Inside the phone is a DSP chip which cancels out background noise, making the call sound much better for all participants. In addition to this, the TR-10 comes with audio recording software, capable of recording your call. On the unit itself, and buttons for controlling the software.

Since the TR-10 installs as a regular audio device, you can even use it for music or movies – and it will almost always sound better than the tiny speakers in your laptop.

The TR-10 is also included in an IPEVO promotion – a two pack is on sale for $99.99.

Final thoughts

Each of these three phones has a different target audience – the $14.99 ST-4RT.1 is ideal for anyone looking for a very basic high quality handset. The FR-33.1 is great for heavy Skype users and the TR-10 is great for all-rounders – it’ll be in its element as a business phone or if you just need a good handset for calling friends and family.

The real winner here is the TR-10. This may be the bulkiest of the three handsets, but I’m loving the ability to use it as a handset, speakerphone and PC speaker. I was not expecting the speakerphone quality to be as impressive as it is – people on the other end of my call could not hear I was sitting back in my chair talking handsfree.

Next week, I’ll be reviewing two more products from IPEVO, their WiFi Skype Phone and a very neat WiFi enabled photo frame – so stay tuned!

Gadling gear review – Panasonic Lumix DMC-TS1 waterproof digital camera

In this Gadling gear review, I’ll introduce you to one of the newest cameras in the Panasonic Lumix lineup. The DMS-TS1 is the first shock and waterproof from Panasonic. The basic specifications are very respectable – 12 megapixel photos, a 4.6x wide angle optical zoom with image stabilization and HD movies recorded in “AVCHD lite”.

Of course, what sets the DMC-TS1 apart from most other digital cameras is its ability to go swimming with you.

The waterproof rating allows you to take the camera in up to 10 feet of water for up to one hour – this is a real underwater rating, not just splashes. In addition to this, it’ll also survive falls up to 5 feet and the design also makes it dust proof.

The design of the camera is awesome – not only do you get a camera that is built to survive the elements, it also looks like it was designed to survive them. A rugged metal frame, and big buttons give it the perfect balance of style and ruggedness.

On the back of the camera are buttons for maneuvering through the menu, switching to playback or video mode and a selector dial for picking the photo mode you want to shoot in.

On the bottom is the battery compartment and memory card slot. These are both behind a waterproof door, protected by a seal. The lock/unlock slider shows a clear red warning when it is not closed correctly.


Photo performance

Photos and video made with the DMS-TS1 look good. For some reason, I did notice that the glass lens picks up more grime than most other cameras, and because it does not feature a (built in) lens cover, I’d recommend bringing a lens wipe with you.

Videos look good – the AVCHD Lite format makes very acceptable 720p HD videos. The audio does leave a little to be desired, as the camera picks up a lot of background noise.

You can transfer files to your PC, or watch them on your HDTV using an HDMI cable. No HD cable is included, so you will have to invest in a MiniHDMI > HDMI cable (about $10 from Monoprice.com) or the Panasonic Component digital cable.

The DMC-TS1 does come with a standard (non-HD) cable and a USB transfer cable. Sadly, the USB cable is a proprietary Panasonic design, so be sure not to lose it.

For most people, the Panasonic Intelligent mode will be more than sufficient – this setting has all the gimmicks you need to make good photos. In scene mode, you can select from 24 different settings. The camera features a dedicated underwater mode, as well as a couple of neat effect modes.

Day to day operation

The DMC-TS1 is fairly snappy, and does not suffer from the slow performance I’ve found on some other Panasonic cameras. Startup time is about 2 seconds, and once on, you can take photos right away. The menu system is very easy to use, and all the features can be accessed very quickly.

My only minor gripe with the operation of the DMC-TS1 is with the zoom slider button. Because it too had to be made waterproof, it is quite hard to operate, and requires a lot of pressure to slide. After a lot of zoom work, your fingers will actually hurt.

Final thoughts

I’m impressed with the DMC-TS1 – it takes all the things I like about the Panasonic Lumix line of cameras, and adds enough protection to turn it into a very travel friendly camera that will be at home on a sightseeing trip, or a day at the beach.

Obviously, the fact that it does not take regular AA or AAA batteries means you’ll need to invest in a second (or third) battery. One word of warning about batteries – the Lumix DMC-TS1 will only work with original Panasonic batteries.

One issue I do want to point out is the warranty – in reading some of the consumer reviews of the DMC-TS1, it would appear that some extra attention is warranted in keeping the camera protected. One of the things that keeps popping up is the recommendation to replace the seals once a year. This is a $140 job. Also, even though the camera is sold as being shock & waterproof, if you do drop it, Panasonic recommends replacing the seals in order to keep it waterproof. This is one of those products that may deserve the extra investment in an extended warranty.

The Panasonic Lumix DMC-TS1 is available in orange, green and silver. Its retail price is $379.99, but many retailers are selling it for just over $300. You’ll find the Panasonic DMC-TS1 are your favorite camera retailer or Amazon.com.