Just how meaningless is the airline elite level?

Christopher Elliott, everyone’s favorite travel consumer advocate has an article posted on CNN that has me scratching my head.

Posted between a discussion of how American Express mishandled a loyalty perk, Elliot claims that airline elite levels are “generally meaningless”.

I’ll leave the American Express debate to Christopher, who has much more experience in dealing with those matters, and focus for a second on his statement about the elite levels.

My initial reaction is “are you kidding me?”. Then, once I calmed down, I decided to think about my own personal experiences with the airlines I fly, and how being an “elite” has helped me over the years.

Lets get one thing out of the way first – a “general member” or even lower tiered “elite” is indeed mainly marketing, and generally meaningless..

Just because you figured out how to sign up for the frequent flier program does not make you an elite, despite waving your blue card at the check in desk, nobody is going to upgrade you.

%Poll-25926%
However, once you prove your loyalty to the airline by flying them enough, they’ll reward you with a shiny card and a pretty decent list of perks. For example; once I had flown enough with British Airways, they made me “gold”, which is their highest (public) tier. With this new card, I was able to use their lounges any time I flew them, and even gain access to their lounge when I was forced to fly a different airline. The card got me upgraded on about 1 in 3 flights, and when I flew with friends, they’d often upgrade them too.

I’d get similar treatment from United Airlines, Lufthansa and BMI. In fact, I don’t recall ever being loyal to an airline and not seeing them prove their love to me. Not once did I ever achieve elite status and wonder why I even bothered.

When I was stranded at an airport after missing my connecting flight, one call to the British Airways Gold desk got me rebooked on the next available flight, without having to stand in line and keep my fingers crossed that they could find me a seat. If I needed a last minute award ticket, the airlines were almost always able to accommodate me. If I booked a flight in coach, a quick trip to their website would get me upgraded, in exchange for one of their complimentary upgrade vouchers. On some long haul flights, such an upgrade could easily be worth $7500. You do the math.

But then it all dawned on me – Chris Elliot does not want you to know about elite levels, and would rather you not bother trying to achieve elite status. Because let’s be honest – the fewer elite fliers there are, the more free seats we’ll see up front for upgrades and the more free food is available in the lounge. At least, that is the only logical reason I could think of.

The world’s most disappointing tourist attractions

The Taj Mahal. La Sagrada Familia. The Grand Canyon. These are places that give visitors goose bumps and must be seen in person. The kinds of places that photographs just can’t do justice. I know that when I arrived at the Taj Mahal my jaw dropped. I was in awe. But not all travel destinations live up to the hype. All to often, you arrive at your prized spot only to snap a perfunctory photo and get back into your rental car feeling disenchanted and cheated. The Sydney Morning Herald did us a solid and put together their list of the world’s most disappointing tourist attractions.

Included on the list are Buckingham Palace (“It’s just a big grey building.”), the Spanish Steps in Rome (“It’s hard to get excited about a flight of stairs…”) and New York’s Times Square (“And what’s there to look at once you arrive? Billboards?”).

I missed the Spanish Steps when I was in Rome because I decided to take a nap instead of joining my friends on that walk. Their reaction when they returned to our apartment? Some shrugged shoulders and a lot of “meh.” And living in New York, I can tell you that Times Square is nothing more than one of Dante’s outer circles of hell, filled with sidewalk hustlers peddling schlock and not much else.

Take a look at their list and let us know what you think. Ever been underwhelmed by a famous landmark? What places have lived up to your high expectations? Drop us a line in the comments.


Click the pictures to learn about some unusual amusement parks, from R-Rated “Love Land,” to a park with a ride called “Dog Fart Switchback.”

Alternatively, click the images to learn about the most unusual museums in the world — covering topics from funeral customs, to penises, to stripping.



Boston real estate developer begs for open Cuba

“Whatever motivated the original break in the U.S.-Cuban relations,” Boston real estate developer Don Chiofaro wrote in a Saturday op-ed piece in the Boston Herald, “it is incomprehensible to me why it continues.” I guess he’s unfamiliar with the Cuban missile crisis and the fear of communism that pervaded the United States while he was growing up.

The topic of Cuba has come up a few times on the pages of Gadling over the past few weeks – and for good reason. Foreign visitors do find the country to be safe, and many have a great time visiting there. Cigar smokers (among which I count myself) eagerly await the day that the borders open and all those illicit Montecristos become legit. More than 45 years have past since the embargo was implemented, and a lot has changed. But, we need to be a tad realistic about the situation.

Cuba is still plagued by an abysmal human rights record, and many Cuban-Americans remember this aspect of their earlier lives without a shred of fondness. The company is ruled not by the vote of the people (even indirectly, as democracy functions up here) but by a single voice that mixes dictatorship with signs of royalty – just note that Fidel Castro turned control of the country over to his brother, Raul.

I’m not supporting the embargo, which I do suspect is anachronistic, but I do suggest that serious thought must be applied to U.S. policy. We need to do more than rely on the observations of a Boston businessman who took advantage of a boondoggle from friends in high places.

More realistically, Chiofaro is stinging from battles with Boston’s mayor, Tom Menino, and still hasn’t fully recovered from the near loss of his prized International Place towers back in 2004 and 2005. Or, the promise of land to be developed has probably caught his eye. Either way, he’s talking without thinking again, as he did when he referred to New York-based property development firm Tishman Speyer as a “gang of pirates.”

C’mon, Don. A builder should know the value of being “constructive.”

[Via Boston Herald]

United Airlines working harder to clean up your mess

United Airlines has always been the airline with the dirty planes, at least as long as I can remember. I’ve often taken flights with sticky armrests, seat pockets filled with crumbs and the general stench of uncleanliness.

The airline had recently been ranked last in class in a JD Powers customer satisfaction survey. A combination of sloppy passengers, increasing delays and decreasing budgets had forced the airline to put cleaning their planes on a low priority.

That survey forced the airline to start paying more attention to its planes, especially in this economic climate, you don’t want to be listed last on any kind or survey.

One of the big changes United made was in the way it tackled how aircraft are cleaned – a new process was implemented, and is making its way to all United Airlines destination cities. The first change was to clean the interior more often. In the past, the airline found it perfectly acceptable to wait 18 months for each “heavy cleaning”, when 30 days is the industry norm. The new schedule calls for a major cleaning every 30 days on domestic aircraft, and 15 days on long haul planes.

The changes are starting to pay off – 40% fewer customers now complain about dirty planes.

In an in-depth article posted by the Chicago Tribune, the reporter was allowed to get up close and personal with the cleaning crew tackling a United 747 that arrived from Hong Kong.

The photos show the kind of damage passengers make when they are stuck inside a metal tube for 16 hours; magazines and other junk is thrown all over the place, apparently passengers feel it is perfectly acceptable to be a bit of a pig when someone else has to clean up their mess. The article also has a gallery of photos showing just how much work is involved in getting a plane ready for a new load of passengers.

Antarctic Cruises: Disaster Waiting To Happen?

With each passing year, more and more adventurous travelers are heading to Antarctica and the icy waters of the Southern Ocean for the unique opportunity of visiting a place that few ever get to see with their own eyes. There has been a lot of discussion in recent years as to the impact of tourism on the fragile environments of the region, but several incidences in recent years call into question the safety of the travelers themselves.

Men’s Journal magazine recently took a look at those dangers wondering “How Long Before the Next Titantic?” The article discusses a couple of high profile accidents in the Southern Ocean, most notably last year’s sinking of the MS Explorer, which sunk rapidly, after it struck an iceberg back in November of 2007. There were a 154 people on board, including passengers and crew. Miraculously, no one was harmed, and rescue ships were on the scene in a matter of hours.

The sinking of the Explorer isn’t the only incident however, either. In January of 2007, the MS Nordkapp struck rocks near Deception Isle, and in December of last year the MV Ushuaia ran aground near Cape Anna as well. Once again, in both cases, no one was hurt, but it makes you wonder if it’s only a matter of time before disaster really does strike.

The Men’s Journal article notes that Antarctic tourism has risen 500% in just 15 years, and that more than 50 ships now operate in the Southern Ocean, shuttling 40,000 passengers in 2008 alone. With that many ships and that many people in such a remote place, are we playing with fire?